In the years marked by tragedy, war, and rising global antisemitism, American and Israeli Jews have experienced a growing sense of shared peoplehood. Despite their different lived experiences, the world’s two largest Jewish communities feel increasingly connected.
Since 2021, the percentage of American Jews who describe Israelis as extended family or community has increased from 46% to 62%, while the percentage of Israeli Jews who feel the same about American Jews has risen from 45% to 53%. Additionally, 79% of Israeli Jews and 56% of American Jews believe that Jews around the world share a common fate.
Research from Jewish Federations of North America, based on parallel studies of American and Israeli Jews, finds that while this connection has deepened, meaningful differences persist on key issues. The findings challenge the assumption that geography is the primary source of these disagreements, revealing that political ideology and religious affiliation play a much greater role in shaping perspectives.
These differences are not simply divisions between American and Israeli Jews. Rather, they reflect the different ideological compositions of the two communities. In other words, left-leaning Jews in both Israel and the United States share similar viewpoints, as do right-leaning Jews in both countries. While a majority of American Jews lean politically left, most Israeli Jews lean right, meaning that political ideology accounts for most of the differences between the two Jewish communities, rather than geography.
- Right-leaning Jews tend to agree that Israel can remain a democracy while maintaining control over the West Bank/Judea and Samaria while left-leaning Jews disagree, resulting in 60% of Israelis holding this view compared to 37% of Americans.
- Jews on the right also view Israeli security and Palestinian statehood as fundamentally incompatible and Jews on the left disagree, resulting in 55% of Israelis holding this view while just 28% of Americans do.
- Left-leaning Jews agree that a two-state solution is the long-term path to peace, while right-leaning Jews disagree, resulting in 50% of Americans and 24% of Israelis.
In both countries, Jews who identify with more traditional forms of Judaism tend to lean further right, while secular Jews and those who identify with more progressive forms of Judaism tend to lean further left.
The research also examined the extent to which Israeli officials should consider the impact of their decisions on American Jews. While large majorities in both communities believe American Jews should be taken into consideration, perspectives vary depending on the issue.
Israeli Jews are more likely to believe the impact on American Jews should be considered on issues of Jewish identity such as when determining who is recognized as a Jew and when making decisions about Aliyah policy. On issues related to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the pattern reverses, with 49% of American Jews and 21% of Israeli Jews believing the impact on American Jews should be considered.
Political ideology plays a significant role in shaping these perspectives, particularly among Israeli Jews. Among American Jews, engagement in Jewish life also influences their interest in questions of Jewish identity in Israel.
The findings emphasize that disagreements often perceived as divisions between American and Israeli Jews are, in fact, disagreements that exist within both communities.
Rebecca Caspi, Senior Vice President for Israel and Overseas and Director General of Jewish Federations of North America's Israel Office, and Mimi Kravetz, Chief Impact and Growth Officer of Jewish Federations of North America, write, “Our tradition teaches that ‘kol yisrael arevim zeh bazeh,’ all Jews are responsible for one another. That responsibility isn’t theoretical. It is the reason we show up for each other in moments that matter. Three years after Oct. 7, our data tell us we are still showing up.”
Regardless of the differences that exist within the communities, American and Israeli Jews can deepen their understanding of one another and engage in meaningful connections across differences. Strengthening Jewish peoplehood does not require eliminating disagreements, but rather investing in the relationships that allow Jewish communities to navigate them together.
The research is based on parallel studies conducted by Jewish Federations of North America examining the perspectives of American and Israeli Jews. Methodology for the American study can be found here, and methodology for the Israeli study can be found here.
Read the full study here.
See the full presentation here.