Dennis, a graduate student in Journalism at Medill University, is a participant in the 'Do the Write Thing' program at the GA for Jewish College Student Journalists.
Immediate Thoughts on Peres' Speech
Simon Peres covered a range of contentious topics – the stumbling economy, oil dependence, the possibility of peace in the Middle East – but his theme and tone remained constant. Peres spoke in the fashion and form of a lullaby: a warm tone of voice, rhythmic pauses between talking points, and a perpetual theme of gentle reassurance.
He opened with the economy, and, as might be expected, the subject was greeted with a quiet buzz of unhappy murmurs from the crowd. Peres sidestepped the negativity by redefining the economy in hopeful terms: Israel's economic strengths are greater than their fiscal returns. Science and technology unlock human potential, and the advancement of knowledge constituted "real wealth." Israel itself is more than a country or a land – it is a future. This soft refocusing removed Israel from the unflattering landscape of statistics and pessimistic realism. Peres ended this portion of his speech with a microcosm of his overall message: there was no need for pessimism, and, "a focus on hope and happiness would make problems disappear sooner."
Peres then moved to the issue of energy, and here, too, he promoted a theme of constant improvement – with Israel at the head. The current system of oil dependence has spawned a host of problems: an expanding chasm between the rich and poor, and an economic crutch for dictators like Chavez, with oil profits contributing to a military machine and terror. But energy alternatives were eminently possible, and could readily contribute to a better world. Peres cited Israel as the most economic in its usage of water and land through its modern science: "…growing vegetables almost without land, fish almost without water…" and in the same theme, energy resources like the sun would soon be harnessed through technological innovation.
Peres sees peace on the horizon as well. First, he discussed the hawkish road towards peace, acknowledging Israel's past military victories - pointing out that losing one would have meant the end of Israel's existence, but "…one day of war does not support one day of democracy…and peace victory is more important than military victory." Peres stated that the road towards peace necessarily involves negotiations and treaties, painful and arduous as they may be. All peace agreements would involve sacrifice, and none would be perfect, but that "…perfection is contrary to existence. Imperfection is a condition to remain alive."
Peres acknowledged Iran as a dangerous presence in the region, one with advanced military capacity, and which would subvert all Middle Eastern states to a theocratic rule. But while he did not downplay the severity of Iran's threat, he also points out that Iran's hostility is something of an inadvertent boon. Iran's imperialist bent is worrying not just for Israel, but the entire Middle East – and thus, has created an unprecedented common ground.
Peres made frequent references to his positive relationship with new President-Elect Obama. Though Obama is arriving, and Peres departing, it remains fitting. Peres built his speech around the foundation of hope: for Israel's economic progression, for the specter of peace becoming more tangible, and above all, in the illimitable capacity of the Jewish people. Now, we must hope he is right.